La Stalla
Rustic · Cozy · Family-Friendly · Homey · Old School
Our weighted 10-point scoring system prioritizes food quality, service excellence, and dining experience, considering cuisine authenticity, professional reviews, and expert evaluations to assess Bucks County's premier restaurants.
The Story
Nestled in a charming converted barn in Newtown, La Stalla offers an authentic Italian dining experience that captures the warmth of a traditional family restaurant. The historic stone and wood accents create a rustic yet elegant atmosphere, transporting diners to the countryside of Italy. With a menu featuring classic dishes like chicken marsala, carbonara, and eggplant rollantini, La Stalla celebrates the rich culinary traditions of Italian cuisine. The restaurant's commitment to quality is evident in their carefully prepared dishes and welcoming service, making it a beloved destination for both locals and visitors seeking a genuine taste of Italy in Bucks County.
Public Sentiment
Diners consistently praise La Stalla for its friendly and attentive service, with many reviewers highlighting the staff's warmth and hospitality. The restaurant's atmosphere receives high marks, with descriptions ranging from 'cozy' to 'rustic elegance'. While food quality is generally positive, some reviewers note inconsistencies, with certain dishes receiving more acclaim than others. The pesto oil, bread, and some pasta dishes are frequently mentioned as standout menu items. The restaurant seems particularly popular for special occasions, with multiple reviews mentioning celebrations like engagement dinners, holiday parties, and family gatherings.
Excellent service · Rustic atmosphere · Family-friendly · Historic venue · Warm hospitality
Best Times to Visit
La Stalla is most vibrant during dinner hours, particularly on Thursday through Saturday evenings between 5:30 PM and 8:30 PM. The restaurant reaches peak occupancy around 7 PM, with Saturday nights being especially bustling. Weekday lunches are more relaxed, offering a quieter dining experience with shorter wait times.
Buzzing
Saturday evenings from 6-8 PM, when the restaurant reaches 90-100% capacity and has a lively, energetic atmosphere.
Relaxed
Weekday lunchtimes and early afternoons, particularly Monday through Wednesday between 11:30 AM and 3 PM, when the restaurant is less crowded.
Location & Getting There
Ratings & Reviews
Information
Address
18 Swamp Rd, Newtown, PA 18940
Phone
(215) 579-8301Website
Visit WebsitePrice Range
$$$
Reservations
Not Required