McCoole's at the Historic Red Lion Inn
Historic · Cozy · Upscale · Intimate · Charming
Our weighted 10-point scoring system prioritizes food quality, service excellence, and dining experience, considering cuisine authenticity, professional reviews, and expert evaluations to assess Bucks County's premier restaurants.
The Story
McCoole's at the Historic Red Lion Inn is more than just a restaurant—it's a living piece of Bucks County history. Nestled in a 1740s building with deep colonial roots, this gastropub offers a unique dining experience that connects guests to the region's rich past. The restaurant played a notable role in the Fries Rebellion, a historic tax revolt, and today continues to be a gathering place for locals and visitors alike. With hand-hewn beams, stone fireplaces, and an intimate atmosphere, McCoole's transports diners to another era while serving contemporary American cuisine. The menu features a delightful mix of pub classics and refined dishes, showcasing local ingredients and culinary creativity.
Public Sentiment
Guests consistently praise McCoole's for its exceptional blend of historic charm and quality dining. The restaurant receives high marks for its welcoming atmosphere, with many reviewers highlighting the cozy interior and knowledgeable staff. Food quality emerges as a strong positive, with specific mentions of delicious crab cakes, prime rib, and creative menu offerings. While most reviews are overwhelmingly positive, a few suggest occasional inconsistencies in service and menu availability. The historic building itself is frequently noted as a major draw, with diners appreciating the unique architectural details and sense of local heritage.
Best Times to Visit
McCoole's is busiest during dinner hours, particularly on Friday and Saturday evenings between 5-8 PM. The restaurant sees peak occupancy around 6-7 PM, with dining rooms filling up quickly. Weekends tend to be more crowded, so reservations are recommended. For a more relaxed experience, consider visiting during weekday lunch hours or early dinner times.
Buzzing
Friday and Saturday evenings from 5-8 PM, with peak crowds between 6-7 PM. The restaurant reaches nearly 100% capacity during these prime dining hours.
Relaxed
Weekday lunch hours and early weekday evenings offer a more quiet dining experience. Wednesday and Thursday afternoons are typically less crowded, providing a more intimate atmosphere.
Location & Getting There
Ratings & Reviews
Information
Address
4 S Main St, Quakertown, PA 18951
Phone
(215) 538-1776Website
Visit WebsitePrice Range
$$
Reservations
Not Required