Oldestone Steakhouse
Our weighted 10-point scoring system prioritizes food quality, service excellence, and dining experience, considering cuisine authenticity, professional reviews, and expert evaluations to assess Bucks County's premier restaurants.
Scores above 8.3 represent outstanding restaurant quality, highlighting Bucks County's premier dining establishments.
The Story
Oldestone Steakhouse transforms a historic church in New Hope into a culinary sanctuary, blending architectural grandeur with contemporary dining excellence. Housed in a beautifully restored ecclesiastical building, the restaurant offers an extraordinary dining experience that marries the building's spiritual heritage with modern gastronomic artistry. Stained glass windows and towering ceilings create a dramatic backdrop for an exceptional steakhouse experience, where premium cuts are prepared with meticulous attention to detail. The multilevel space, featuring a ground floor bar and an elegant dining room, invites guests to enjoy not just a meal, but a sensory journey through New Hope's rich cultural landscape.
Public Sentiment
Guests consistently praise Oldestone's unique atmosphere and transformative dining experience. While most reviews highlight exceptional service and delicious steaks, there's a nuanced appreciation for the restaurant's architectural beauty. Some diners note occasional inconsistencies in service speed and meal preparation, but these are often overshadowed by the restaurant's overall charm. The converted church setting receives particular acclaim, with many describing it as a 'must-visit' destination that transcends typical dining expectations.
Best Times to Visit
Weekend evenings, particularly Saturday nights, offer the most vibrant dining experience. Peak hours between 6-8 PM showcase the restaurant at its busiest and most energetic. Reservations are strongly recommended during these times, as the restaurant fills quickly with both locals and visitors seeking a memorable dining experience.
Buzzing
Saturday evenings from 5-8 PM, with 100% occupancy during peak dinner hours. Friday nights also bustling with high energy and near-full capacity.
Relaxed
Weekday early evenings (4:30-6:30 PM) offer a more tranquil dining experience, with lower occupancy and a calm atmosphere perfect for a leisurely meal.
Location & Getting There
Ratings & Reviews
Information
Address
15 S Main St, New Hope, PA 18938
Phone
(215) 862-7044Website
Visit WebsitePrice Range
$$$$
Reservations
Not Required